Thank you all for giving me your input on what color to paint my front door. I purposely didn't tell you what color I had in mind because I didn't want to sway your opinion. Four months ago I stood on the porch and went through every possible paint color option and landed on English Tea Party.
Then I started to second guess myself. Thank you Anna for putting my mind at ease with my selection and suggesting a dark brown. I do think that black would have been okay, but I really think that the brown will give it just the touch of warmth that is lacking in the current color scheme.
After looking at a few colors online I think I want to check out Black Walnut in person too. Now I just have to get motivated to tackle another painting project.
What color is your front door?